My friend Richard wrote an insightful post on Measuring Writing Success and I think you should all check it out. I especially like that he broke down the measurements into three categories: Ambition, Perseverance, and Dedication to Craft.
I have some thoughts I’d like to add on the subject. Before I do, here is a quick update on some unrelated topics:
- Write Something Good episode 7 is up, and I think it’s better than 5 and 6. It’s more heartfelt and less edited. There should be a doodly-doo at the top to take you to links for the podcast. Here is the YouTube link, if you’re interested in the video.
- Once again, Melissa, Bryanna, and I are heading to LA on Thanksgiving to participate in Loscan 52. I’ll be in the dealer’s room quite a bit, as well as participating on the following 3 panels:
- Time Travel Theories in Science Fiction on Friday at 1PM
- How to Sell Books as an Independent Author on Sunday at 10AM (moderating)
- Publishing, A.I. and how to keep ahead of the curve on Sunday at 1PM
- There is no third main bullet point
I’m not entirely sure how I got on the AI panel, and I wonder how it’s going to play out. The panel description makes me think that it’s going to be pro-AI, or at least leaning towards acceptance of AI in the writing/publishing world. Meanwhile, I’m dedicating time and attention towards telling people to leave AI alone and trust their own voice. It’s possible this panel could get spicy. It’s also at 1PM on the final day, so it may be unattended and a complete non-issue. We’ll find out soon!
With that bit of housekeeping out of the way, let’s get to the main topic.
Measuring Success in Writing
In Richard’s post, he focuses on how he’s measuring his own success, and he rightly implies that those measurements change over time.
For my take on the subject, I will talk about how I measure my success, and also provide some suggestions for how others might building their own measurements.
To begin, writing is a journey, not a destination. There are destinations along the way, and there are milestones, but we are all different, our paths as writers are all different, and while many of us have much in common, we are all at different stages along our writing journey.
A helpful takeaway from that is: It does not benefit us to measure our writing journey against the writing journeys of other people. It does me no good to weigh my successes against those of Steven King, Richard S. Crawford, or anyone else.
Sticking with the journey analogy, our various writing paths wind around, dipping into valleys and attempting to climb mountains. Some parts are easier than others, and sometimes it is easier to see where we’re going. Other times, it seems like we’re stuck in a quagmire. This leads to a second takeaway: There is no failure. There is only the points along the road where we stop, and there is nothing that says we can’t start going again after a long rest.
Let’s focus for a moment on milestones and destinations. Since our paths are all different, where we’re going may also be different, though there are common destinations. A long time ago, when I was writing about Fears of the Writer and talking about different ways I was afraid I’d fail, I mentioned the following, which could be considered a list of destinations:
How does one fail as a writer? I think there are lots of steps along the way.
- Get an idea for a story, but never start.
- Start the story, but never finished the first draft.
- Finish the first draft, but never edit it.
- Edit it, but never show it to anyone.
- Show it to people, but never submit it for publication.
- Receive rejection letters, but never get over them.
- Get the story published, but no one ever reads it.
- Finish the first story, and never start the next.
As far as destinations go, they’re not bad. Careers are built on writing one book at a time, one word at a time, and the list cleanly follows the birth and triumph of a story.
There are other destinations, however, some of which may seem well off the beaten path:
- Attend the next writing event
- Write the next blog post
- Read the next book on writing advice
- Participate on a panel on writing
- Moderate a panel on writing
- Interview someone for a podcast
- Start a podcast dedicated to telling people not to give up their voice to the machines
These are all parts of my writer journey, many of which don’t look like writing at all.
Richard’s post is a kind of self-evaluation, where Richard took a step back in order to see where he is and determine if he’s heading in the direction that he wants to go. He took some writing time away from his 65,000+ novel to check the map, as it were. There’s value in that. We should all take a moment and ask, “Am I doing what I want to be doing?” and then make corrections accordingly.
About three years ago, I wrote a similar post on Measure Success as an Author that leaned less into the path analogy and more into a discrete list of categories: money, joy, and fame. In that post, the formula for success is: skill + time + luck = success
My Advice For Measuring Success
The formula listed above is true. You can improve your skills, you can spend more time, and you can give yourself more opportunities for luck to strike. Conveniently, this overlaps some with the categories Richard used to measure his own success.
- Ambition: Attempt to write stories that challenge you and force you to grow as a writer. This will improve your skills over time, which will in turn help you ultimately achieve greater levels of success. Ambition may also mean submitting your work to agents and publications, overcoming the inner demons that feed your fears around submissions. The more you put your work out there, the more opportunity you have for luck to shine.
- Perseverance: To me, this is more about overcoming your fears and trepidation in order top put in the time to draft. Perseverance is also the ability to overcome rejection and put your work out there, overlapping with the benefits of Ambition.
- Dedication to Craft: This is again about improving your skillsets, which can go along with Ambition in writing work that challenges you. It can also be attending panels, listening to podcasts, and reading craft books which provide ideas and concepts for you to engage and apply to your writing.
A self-evaluation of where you are on your writer’s journey should include an honest assessment of what time you have available to dedicating to writing and editing, and it should include a list of objectives, which are destinations along your path.
You should look at which stories you want to write, and where you are in the process of finishing that work. “Finish” might mean publication, or it might mean getting to a state that you can submit to your critique group, or it might mean something else entirely. Determine what “finish” means, and then evaluate where your stories are on the way to being finished.
Once you have your list, check to see if it includes enough elements that feed into the formula. How much of what you are planning is ambitious enough to help you improve your skills? Have you put enough details into your plan that you can dedicate time to actually finish your stories and achieve your goals? Are you doing enough to improve your skillset outside of drafting and editing?
Have enough humility that you can acknowledge that there are places where you can grow as a writer. But also, have enough pride or sense of self-worth to know that your voice is unique and your stories have value, and what you have to say deserves to be out in the world. Maintain the balance between pride and humility while looking at where you are on your path, because too much pride or humility will send you off course.
Finally, be honest. Don’t be too hard on yourself or cruel, but also don’t let yourself off the hook when you know you can do better. You can be honest with yourself about your progress while simultaneously giving yourself grace when your haven’t achieved your goals.
Let me know what you think. Is there anything I’ve left out? Do you have writer goals, and are you achieveing them?